Wednesday, December 5, 2007

What Do You Want To Hear?


From Mitt Romney about his Mormon faith?


In 1960, the south was very concerned about John F. Kennedy's Catholic faith so much that it prompted him to address the potential voters about it. It was enough to put to rest the issues that the Protestant south had about him.


So what will have to be said from Romney in order to put to rest the conservative Christian base of the Republican party?



Romney to take on issue of his Mormon faith
Wed Dec 5, 2007 7:04pm EST
By Steve Holland
WASHINGTON (Reuters) - Trying to save his presidential campaign from an Iowa swoon, Republican Mitt Romney on Thursday will take on the issue of his Mormon faith by stressing America's tradition of religious tolerance.


Romney is to make remarks at the presidential library of former President George H.W. Bush in College Station, Texas, not far up the road from Houston, where Democratic candidate John Kennedy in 1960 used a speech to ease concerns about his Catholic faith and went on to win the presidency.


Romney, a former governor of Massachusetts, would be the United States' first Mormon president, although a number of followers of the religion hold elected U.S. positions, several of them in the Senate, such as Senate Majority Leader Harry Reid of Nevada.


The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints has an estimated 6 million members in the United States and is based on the belief that the religion's founder, Joseph Smith, found golden tablets in upstate New York left behind by ancient Israelites.


Some Americans view the Mormon faith with skepticism and the church has spent decades trying to counter criticism that it is a cult and a threat to Christianity.


A recent survey by the Pew Research Center found that a majority of Americans view the Mormon faith as a Christian religion, but one in four respondents said they would be less likely to vote for a Mormon president.


Romney's most immediate challenge is in Iowa, where the wide lead he once held has now faded, with former Arkansas Gov. Mike Huckabee winning support from Christian evangelicals to catch Romney in the polls.


Iowa on January 3 holds the first of the state-by-state contests to determine which Republican and Democrat will face off in the November 2008 election. A win there can generate momentum, while a loss can deflate presidential hopes.


"The timing of this speech is a direct result of Huckabee's surge in Iowa and Romney's softening numbers," said a veteran Republican strategist in Washington. "The target is social conservatives in Iowa and South Carolina and being 'acceptable' to them."


'FAITH IN AMERICA'


Romney decided on his own to give a speech with the title of "Faith in America."
"This speech is an opportunity for Governor Romney to share his views on religious liberty, the grand tradition religious tolerance has played in the progress of our nation and how the governor's own faith would inform his presidency if he were elected," said Romney spokesman Kevin Madden.


Or, as Romney told CBS News: "I'm not running for pastor-in-chief. I'm running for commander-in-chief."


Experts doubt Romney will talk much about the specifics of his religion.
"The question about Governor Romney's candidacy is not a question about what it means to be a Mormon. The question is about what it means to be president of the United States and respect religion without allowing religion to dictate decisions in the Oval Office," said Welton Gaddy, a Baptist preacher who heads the Interfaith Alliance.


Nancy Ammerman, a professor of the sociology of religion at Boston University, said it is a speech Romney had to give.


Americans need to be reassured that "he really does believe in the separation of church and state and that he does come into the political arena as someone who should be judged on his policies and his record," she said.


Barry Lynn, executive director of the Americans United for the Separation of Church and State, said Romney's speech is another chapter in a U.S. presidential campaign where religion has played a big role.


Huckabee has talked about being a Baptist preacher, Republican Fred Thompson was quizzed on how often he goes to church, and Democrat John Edwards was asked about his biggest sin.
"Frankly this whole election cycle is turning into some kind of theological beauty pageant instead of an electoral campaign for the presidency," he said.


(To read more about the U.S. political campaign, visit Reuters "Tales from the Trail: 2008" online at blogs.reuters.com/category/events/trail08/)

31 comments:

sarah lambert said...

Okay so first of all JFK rocks, just thought ya'll should know that. Well if Romney's speech is half as good as JFK's then he will be on a preetty good start. But his speech is going to have to be really really brilliant because most people see Mormons as a cult. No offense to all those Mormons. Religion shouldn't be the deciding factor in electing the president. But if Romney is having his speech in the same area where JFK had his address speech then he's going to have some pretty high standards to live up to. But we shouldn't judge him by his religion. All his religion does is help us to get to know him. But his speech better be like mind boggling good.

Sarah Lambert
Human Geography AP
9th grade

Cheyenne Bell said...

Though i'm not particularly religious, I think this needing to know what religion the candidates are is ridiculous. So what if he's a Mormon? In my opinion, people only want to know what religion the candidates are so that they rule them out if they don't agree. I didn't plan on supporting Romney anyway but give him a break-I think we shoud all take a deep breath and try to be more tolerant of "unacceptable" religions.

Abigail Ham said...

Religion is something that shouldn't be brought into debates. After thinking about this discussion from Wednesday, I think that a candidate's religion should not be questioned. I forgot about the 1st amendment, and after hearing it applied to this situation, Americans have no right to base their voting opinions on the candidate's religion. That isn't to say that they won't, of course.
As for how often one goes to church or one's biggest sin, well, that's between God and the person, isn't it? Those questions are more personal than political, they shouldn't matter.
After all, if they can make promises to make the world (or America) better and keep those promises, then their attendance to service and past sins shouldn't be mentioned in their resume.
If Romney wants to say something about his faith, then he can, that's his choice. BUT if Huckabee, Thompson, and Edwards don't want to say anything, then DADGUMIT! They shouldn't have to!

Abigail Ham
4th period
9th grade

Millie Dorsett Period 3 said...

So, i laughed when i read that Romney said, "I'm not running for pastor-in-chief. I'm running for commander-in-chief." Romney makes a good point though. A presidential candidate's religious beliefs really shouldn't be a deciding factor in whether they get elected president, and we shouldn't hate or discriminate against him just because his beliefs may be different from those of our own. I agree with Sarah when she said that his speech is going to have to be really brilliant because most people consider Mormonism, a cult. I know i hear it around, and i understand that religion is a big part of the person and may influence his decisions as president, but I also believe you shouldn't cross out him as a possibility, just because his religious views are different.


Millie Dorsett
Human Geography AP
10th Grade
Period 4

Aaron Gonzalez said...

this speech could very well help him by showing alot of people that even though hes morman hes still perfectly capable of running the country since his religion dosnt effect his ability to do so. then again it might not do much at all to help or hurt him.

Dylan B said...

It shouldnt matter what religion Romney is. Just because he is a different religion than you are does not mean you shouldnt vote for him. What should matter is wether or not he is qualified and has the good ethics and morals to be our next president

Dylan Boyd
10th grade
4th period
Human Geography

Dylan B said...

It shouldnt matter what religion Romney is. Just because he is a different religion than you are does not mean you shouldnt vote for him. What should matter is wether or not he is qualified and has the good ethics and morals to be our next president

Dylan Boyd
10th grade
4th period
Human Geography

annie henderson 4th said...

I'm glad Romney's giving the speech about his religion. I do agree that religion shouldn't be the deciding factor on whether or not you vote for someone, but i still feel it's okay to know. I'm not going to vote for anyone that I don't know absolutely everything I can about. If someone's going to be making decisions that could influence my life, I want to know where they stand on something that's as important to me as religion. Kudos for Romney.

Annie Henderson
AP Human Geography
9th grade

Grant Curry said...

My goodness. What a world we live in where a presidential canidate has to make an appeal to the public for his religon to be tolerated! Romney, by NO means should have to make a speech to "pardon" his religous belifes. But politics is a game i suppose and he wants to win so even if the rules are currupt he still has to play by them. Its just so frustrating to live in a world were to get anywhere your forced to support or at least sustain things that are completely wrong.

Grant Curry
4th Period
9th Grade
AP Human Geography

Evan said...

I don't think that when it comes down to the final point, religion should'nt be top priority. Yes it is important, but leadership and morality are stronger characteristics. The world should be a big Harmony of religions.(Mormons included)

Cydnee said...

Cydnee Prince
3rd Period

No, religion shouldn't be a deciding factor in your vote. Like Romney says, he's not running for pastor-in-chief. Truth of the matter is though, many people in the U.S. have strong religious beliefs and would easily be swayed if a presidentidial candidate lacked similar values. It's especially unfortunate and counterproductive that Romney is of a belief system some call a cult. And while I won't need to hear his speech on religion, some most definitely will need to hear it to even consider casting their vote for him.

Jessica Kaskie said...

Although I don't support Romney, I believe he could get many votes in the long run from simply being different. His religion may make him unique to many people, and all of the publicity may make a lot more voters recognize him. However, Romney really has to make a wonderful speech to get ahead in the elections. I think religion is one of the many important factors in politics, but it shouldn't be the deciding one. Besides, even though Mormons aren't exactly like Christians, we both belive in some of the same things.
Jessica Kaskie
4th period
9th grade

nolan reyher said...

Since so many people are concerned about Romney's religion, giving a speech addressing it could very well help him in his campaign for the presidency. However I believe that someone’s religion should not be that much of a deciding factor. All religions basically have the same moral values of being a good person, therefore it doesn’t matter what religion they are.

Unknown said...

People simply need to remember that we need someone to run a country, not a church.

Not voting for Romney based on his religion is like not voting for Giuliani because of his multiple marriages.

If Romney has good ideas, values, and knows the direction he wants to take the country then being a Mormon should not affect the United States.

People should research further into the views of their candidates instead of just glancing at what church they attend, and how often they do so.

Chelsea Huffhines
4th Period
Human Geography AP
9th grade

Flip121 said...

Romney's speech although I have not heard it yet is a very good move on his part. Mormonism is a sometimes a problem with "traditional Christians" in the fact that some believe it is an off shoot of Christianity and others believe that it is so far fetched and believe it is another religion altogether. Romney's decisive move in this speech is if he tells the people whether or not his religion is going to be apart of his decision making or if he will strictly stand by the constitution and reassuring Christian voters that it is an off shoot of Christianity not some mad cult machine by the use of the statistics said in this post.

Robert Marshall
Gov't
Senior 08

Stephen Puente said...

I believe religious views do tell us some about the candidates, but our vote should not depend on this one aspect. A president's religion does not necessarily equal the policy he will make- though it may have influence.
Any candidate under fire has two possible outcomes: to bend and break under the pressure, or prove they can defend themselves and be commended for their handling of the situation. Romney's religious pressures are playing in his favor; I believe he's impressed more people than lost, as a result.
He shows strong qualities we seek as president -IF religious conservative voters will take the advise to give him a chance- he may have a shot at the nomination.

Stephen Puente (Period 6)

savedraanjelica said...

Anjelica Savedra
4th period
9th grade
I think Romney's speech speech is breater than JFK's speech. Religion is a good factor on electing a president. If the president says what religion he is we get a beeter oppenting to know him. SORRY about being late on writing can you still accept it.

Unknown said...

Chandra Carpenter
Government AP
3rd Period

This is a great opportunity for Mitt Romney to address voters who base their vote on religion. Whether or not you believe that religion should be a factor in voting for president, the reality is that many people do vote based on a candidate's faith. By making the first move, Romney makes it seem like he isn't hiding his religion, and that his ethics and morals are strong.

Samantha Reid said...

Personally I don't really care if Romney is a Mormon. I really doubt that his faith would alter his ability to lead the country so I don't really see why it's that big of a deal.

AlanLopez said...

To me it seems that with all this concentration on the republicans, the democrats don't really seems to have a good chance of winning the presidency. If Romney can deliver a good speech and distinguish clearly that his religion wont interfere with his presidential decisions, then I believe the Christian majority will support his campaign.

Alan Lopez
World Topics/Government
5th/6th period.

Johnny C. said...

Having a speech adressing his religion could very well help his numbers. He needs to get the general public to focus not on his religion, but his views on matters pertaining to the country. As he siad he is not running for pastor-in-chief, he is running for commander-in-chief

Kali Elliott said...

I think that while it is important to know your presidential candidates religious beliefs, it should not be your deciding factor in your electoral vote.

No matter how religious he is or what religion he believes in, he could still suck at his job, which is being the president of the united states (hypothetically speaking, of course.)
Or, even if he is not religious at all, he could be GREAT at his job.

Kali Elliott
4th Period

jayrussellburrous said...

mitt romney is a legit canidate for president. he is a smart and successful man that knows what he is doing. although he is a morman it should not affect his canadicy. religion does not play a large role in being president.

jayrussellburrous said...

Mitt Romney is a very successful and smart man. He should not be scrutinized for being a Morman. He should not have to give a speech explaining why he is the way he is. To be the president of the U.S. religion should not play a major role.

Gizmo said...

I don't believe that the religion of the candidate(in this case Romney)should be a factor in the selection of a political figure or president. Their actions thusfar and their values/morals should be the closest things we need to know to their religion. Questioning them and there abilities based on their religion is wrong and if we have questions we should go to the library or get on the internet and look up the religion and become more informed. If after doing that we still don't understand or agree then we can form are opinion. But shunning or questioning the candidate for their religion without at least a base knowledge of it is a failure on our part and a product of ignorance. This speach is his chance to clear any misconseptions and could very well save him if people are willing to listen.

This is Michael Maeker By the Way!!!

Keti Tsereteli said...

Keti Tsereteli
Period 4
10th grade

Religion should never have been or continue to be an issue. Sadly, it will remain a crucial factor in many people's minds. It provides them with a false sense of security, something they can clutch to instead of completely reviewing all the qualifications of the candidate and making the difficult decision. They need some kind of guarantee that they made the right decision, and religion just happens to provide that. With Romney, his religious views should not matter; they should simply provide more, albeit somewhat trivial, information about him.

Unknown said...

I believe religion IS a very important deciding factor when it comes to voting for who will be in charge of the country you live in. Its true that just because you say you are "religious" does not mean that you have good morals, or that you are a good person. But the fact that a candidate is not ashamed of what he believes and is not afraid of everyone knowing what his beliefs are is definitely a plus. If a candidate for the presidential office allows himself to be known as a Christian and publicizes that he will stand for Christian morals, right there, he [or she] is giving the people a standard he must try to live up to.

Johanna Bauersfeld
Human Geography
4th

Gizmo said...

although i have only heard Romney once on religion, i was very displeased with his answer. most people sat that religion and debate/politics should not be mixed, which makes since to an extent because when youre ask about religion in debate its not going to come across very well if you just ignore or avoind the question. stumbling over the question wont win you any points either, and thats just what Romney did at the YouTube debate. If you believe in something enough to make it your religion, you should not be ashamed or afraid to answer a question regarding it. so basiclly what im saying is if he doesnt think the american people will like him because of his religion why is he even running in the first place?

Austin Moore
3rd period
Senior

Paddy said...

I still don't think that the faith of a candidate is not an important reason for his election. JFK is the best example, many people were concerned about his catholic believes,but in th end it didn't really matter for his political campaign. I think people should learn from that and theu should not make their vote dependent on a candidates faith, more on his political believes

Patrick Gutekunst
US Government 6th Period
11th Grade

Stephanie said...

In my opinion knowing what the canidates religious beliefs is not important in electing a president because we aren't following his religion but his own actions as a person. But to others it is all about how they think the candidate will enforce his beliefs on to the american people. So its a no win sitituation for everyone.

Unknown said...

I don't believe that the religion of the candidate(in this case Romney)should be a factor in the selection of a political figure or president. Their actions thusfar and their values/morals should be the closest things we need to know to their religion. Questioning them and there abilities based on their religion is wrong and if we have questions we should go to the library or get on the internet and look up the religion and become more informed. If after doing that we still don't understand or agree then we can form are opinion. But shunning or questioning the candidate for their religion without at least a base knowledge of it is a failure on our part and a product of ignorance. This speach is his chance to clear any misconseptions and could very well save him if people are willing to listen.

This is Michael Maeker By the Way!!!