By HUGO RESTALL who writes in the Wall Street Journal
To all the other superlatives used to describe China we may now add the fact that it has the tastiest cigarettes. I don't pretend to be a connoisseur, having only begun smoking a couple weeks ago, but then again I've been inhaling the smoke of Chinese cigarettes for years.
The country consumes about one-third of the world's cigarettes. As a student, I often carried a pack just to offer to others. Want to start a conversation on a train in China? Shake the pack. Asking directions? Hold out a stick and say, "chou yi ger." If the guy is already smoking, he'll tuck it behind his ear for later.
After years of resisting, a friend in Shanghai gave me the perfect excuse to start smoking. China has become so polluted, he told me, that it's better to breathe through a cigarette filter than just take in the air on its own. And if your lungs are going to get shot to hell anyway, you might as well enjoy it. So, well into middle age, I figured that it was probably a good time to take up the smoking habit.
The result? I enjoy it so much that I don't know why I didn't take it up earlier.
For the Chinese, smoking carries connotations that might seem outdated, even quaint to Westerners. Real men smoke, period. And when real men hang out together, they smoke a lot. The presence of women is appreciated, of course -- if they are quick with a lighter. At a formal meal or banquet, each course may be followed by a cigarette, as if to cleanse the palate, and a few more cigarettes will be smoked at the end, in place of port. As the saying goes, fan hou yi zhi yan, sai guo huo shenxian -- a cigarette after a meal and you feel better than a living god.
Mao Zedong and Deng Xiaoping smoked like chimneys, even when they were meeting foreign dignitaries. The government provided its leaders with top-quality tobacco. The best cigarette brands, many manufactured in Shanghai on the equipment confiscated from the capitalists in 1949, conferred an aura of power. Limited production now helps them retain their cachet.
Mao reportedly favored a brand called Chunghwa, which means China. These cigarettes always came in a distinctive red packet, the color of the Forbidden City walls, embossed with the Gate of Heavenly Peace in gold, although without Mao's portrait. Perhaps, for Mao, it would have been too strange to see his own face smiling back at him from his cigarette box. Deng smoked the elusive Pandas, which had a campy, 1960s look to them -- psychedelic orange packaging and cartoon of pandas snacking on bamboo.
These brands are still around, of course. But puffing on the same lights as dead dictators doesn't come cheap. Chunghwas run you almost $10 a pack, and Pandas, if you can find them, are $12. But it's worth it. Not only do they offer a pungent sense of history, they taste fantastic. Both are exceptionally smooth, almost like an Indonesian kretek clove cigarette. But they kick like a Camel unfiltered.
Pandas are made with a dark tobacco and hence are woody and nutty, with hints of pine shavings and hickory. They are a bit strong, and have a very long filter to compensate. But they leave a spicy aftertaste, which perhaps is why Deng, who was from Sichuan, the land of chilies and peppercorns, loved them so much.
When you open a pack of Chunghwa cigarettes, you can smell the bouquet of preserved plums, and they convey a fruity flavor even when alight. If smoking puts you on the road to early death, as some spoilsports say, then Chunghwas make the journey an extremely pleasant one. I would go so far as so say that, if you ever find yourself in the unfortunate position of being offered a last cigarette, make it a Chunghwa. This is a smoke to be savored like a vintage wine.
Many of the scents of the old China are disappearing, like the smoke of the feng wo mei, charcoal powder pressed into the shape of a honeycomb that was once burned in most households for cooking and heat. But cigarettes, at least, remain. It used to be that, whenever a man exhaled off his cheap cigarette, it would transport me back to my student days and the "hard seat" train compartments where I would almost be asphyxiated by clouds of smoke. Now that man might be me.
43 comments:
Landon Henderson
Pd. 7th
Grade: 9th
I never like the thought of anyone smoking. That guys excuse for smoking does not seem right. I mean that there is never a reason to smoke.
Next time I asphyxiate, dear China, I shall think of you!
Such a loving, sentimental tone in this little article. If ever I smoke, I'll be able to justify it now, pushing the blame onto my good ol' high school education.
You know, a lot of people seem to have problems with the whole "smoking section/non-smoking section" idea. Complaints by non-smokers of the smoke traveling cause many people to push for anti-smoke-section legislation. But this, fellow Lubbock High students, is a leap of logic in air. You are condemning smoking sections and, by extension, smokers themselves, just because the smoke happens to travel from them to the non-smoking sections. But they have no control of the smoke after it is released! Why, condemning an individual for the damage done by secondhand smoke is as unreasonable as convicting a man of murder just because of what his bullet did after it left the gun! No, friends, we as a society are in error, and the sooner we realize this, the better. We do not need anti-smoking legislation, just as we do not need anti-homicide legislation! We focus our energies on the wrong problem, can't you see? We must pass legislation to force the smoke, by LAW, to stay in the smoking section. Most smoke I know never sets out to hurt anybody, at least not intentionally--if we pass the laws, I'm sure the smoke will listen and stay in its confined area. It's time that our legislators learn to fix the problem instead of unnecessarily restricting our rights to skirt the very problem itself.
Reading this made me think, though (which is unusual for me, because I rarely think). Lubbock High's Math and Science Team has a disproportionately high number of Chinese competitors, right? And this article clearly shows that all Chinese people are chimneys (stereotypes, of course, always apply). The article also provides me with the excellent information of which cigarettes might appeal most to these Chinese guys. So if I can get them hooked...yes...then distract them when they should be taking tests...yesyes...finally, white people may have a hope for the future in this world! Look out, China, panda power may yet relinquish its crown to the power of the whitey!
Always knew George Huang was a big-time smoker at heart.
Goodness. That's a lot of information I didn't expect to come across on the government web site. Still, interesting stuff. I'm sure tobacco is an incredibly profitable business venture in China these days. Maybe I should change career plans.
Casey Farmer- 3rd
I like how it talks about how Mao smoked...really, not the best role model guys.
also, I don't think that smoking could really better for you than breathing pollution. pollution doesn't give you bad breath, I'd like to add.
As Americans its easy for us to find the Chinese people's habitual activity of smoking enduring, especially with the constant anti-smoking ads and propaganda that are presented to us daily. But I find it easy to contrast the Chinese people's smoking habits to our habits as Americans to eat unnutritious food. I believe the answer is a form of culture for each country. The Chinese people in a sense have a very conservative and generally healthy diet opposed to our conventional American diet. Our understanding of their smoking habits is just as foreign as their understandings of our diet. Once again I find their habits (which are so different than our own) are just a form of culture that Americans aren't used to.
Hahaha! This is definitely my favorte English reading so far in 2008. I was thinking about the same thing as I read the article: "fan hou yi zhi yan, sai guo huo shen xian." When I was small. Every day after dinner, my father will go to the back yard and smoke. When I asked him why. He smiled and told me that saying. He smokes Chunghwa, too. The "chou yi ger" really made me laugh. I guess the writer has a pretty heavy Northern accent.
I hate smoking and smokers. After I turned to 10, everytime I saw my father or grandfather smoking, I would tell them to stop. Finally my grandfather quit smoking! But my father is still a smoker...
I don't know about other part of China, but in the cities close to my hometown and my hometown, people never smoke in a formal public place like supermarkets, banks, malls and restaurants, etc(and definitely not on an airplane...). At least I never see them smoking. I have heard that some cities started making laws about public smoking.
Though I don't like the smell of smoke, I still think there should be more public places where people can smoke, other than bars--or can you even smoke in there anymore?
Gillian Welch
3rd
Is this an exaggeration or is smoking really THAT important to the Asian culture?
I find it disappointing that a cigarette can be depended on for conversation-starters.
There isn't anything wrong with smoking but such emphasis is ridiculous. Spending $10 - $12 for a pack of cigarettes is silly and a waste of money.
I suppose I can imagine what it would be like to fly in a "smoking" section - the same as it is in restaurants and hotel rooms where smoking is allowed.
I imagine smoking does stick out in such a country...but it's sad to think that such a custom is what society is coming to.
While I am a total nay smoker, it's kinda like the whole alcohol thingy...you know it's bad what good can come from it? But it's partly social, partly habit, partly what you've grown up with it all depends on your taste whether to drink in this case smoke or not. Besides drinking brings people together as I would imagine so does smoking. Even food to an extent is bad for you, but it's a social thing that people do to get together and catch up (I know it's a necessity) it makes things run smoother. A lil old aged? In this hemisphere yes but China is a lasting world power so can we really doubt their social culture?
George Huang
6th Period
Heh, it's true that smoking cigarettes is rampant in China; I have two uncles who smoke and they refuse to quit. Also, it's true that the air quality in urban areas gets worse every year because of increased construction - in fact, our plane leaving Shanghai this Christmas was delayed 2 hours because of smog. As for the flavors of these cigarettes, I can't confirm or input anything except that they smell horrible.
Despite all this smoking, Chinese facilities are very poorly ventilated. Sales associates in malls constantly smoke when they have no customers, and on trains, when one person decides to smoke, it drifts down the entire car. When I was stuck in the hospital this Christmas, someone in a nearby room decided to start smoking and I couldn't leave because I was stuck to an IV and too weak to walk - it was miserable.
Abigail Ham
9th grade
4th period
My grandad smoked for most of his life. He had several heart attacks. We watched him wither away, unable to continue to create his masterpieces of wood. He was a master... I never got to learn from him, thanks to cigarettes. For our birthdays, when we were really little, he made wooden carosel horses for us, hand painted and hand carved by him. He, my great grandfather, and my dad built a cabin the old fashioned way in the mountains of New Mexico near Blue Haven. He was a zealous Christian his whole life, he was strong in his beliefs and respected above everything in the household. He didn't do this by smoking. He didn't have to. He was a man, the real kind of man, who didn't need a smelly weed to prove to the world what he was. He spent the last 14 years of his life suffering, watching his family watch him suffer, watching countless paychecks go to cigarettes that he didn't want but had to have. Watching his only son's daughters come to visit and not be able to say anything because he was too tired or winded. Watching his life, which could have been spent teaching his grandchildren his art-the creating of life in wood carvings- instead waste away. He died a man, but not because of cigarettes.
I can't convince anyone smoking is bad. I'll leave that to the FDA, and the examples of healthy lung pictures versus a smoker's lung's picture. Thanks for the referrals to certain brands of smokes, I'm sure you meant well. But for me, the Chinese can die how they want. I think, however, that there are much cooler ways to die.
2nd period
I have heard smoking stunts your growth. Well that woould explain why most of the chinese people are short haha. So Yao must have not smoked. Let's just hope the chinese keep smoking or they will all end up like yao and the US will never beat them in basketball again.
I don't see why people pay money for cigarettes and constantly smoke when they know the effects of it. It doesn't make sense to me. A few of my family members smoke and half of the time they sound like they're are gonna die from so much coffing. Plus, all of the money they spend on cigarettes....Definitely not worth it.
i laughed when they were interesting that real men smoked and that primarily it was men around, but women could too, " if they were quick with a lighter." ha. it was funy. but overall i would have to say it was pretty funny and interesting to hear about the ways and traditions behind ciggerettes. but yes, very interesting, but mostly funny.
millie dorsett
period 4 Human Geography AP
10th grade
Being born in China, I definitely know the situation. A few decades ago, many people worked on farms and their only daily pleasure was their cigarettes. Even a lot of women smoked too. Basically, you can see people just standing there, minding their own business and smoking. But i guess it's kind of late for that change now.
Jiaqi Niu
HuGeo AP 4th
10th Grade
Peter Young
Chairman Mao had a lot of habits during his term of power, including smoking, refusing to bathe or brush his teeth, and pimping women like Bond.
Chinese people have been smoking for a long time, some 300 million people are smoking recreationally or when considered appropriate by society. Tobacco and opium are very plentiful in China. Smoking is bad, don't smoke.
So the Chinese smoke a lot... Hmmm, this article was mediocre. Sounds like they found a way to condence the harmful effects of Hookah into a cigarette. I suppose they aren't aware of, or really just don't care how damaging these things can be. Although I wasn't surprised when I read about the writer's friend saying that breathing through a cigarette filter was better than breathing the actual air around him. If we want to slow down the effects of global warming, it's going to take many more countries to coorperate, especially China. I may be ignorant with how they are dealing with the global warming issue, but I think at this rate, they need to step it up.
Gabriel Quinteros, 2nd Period
I do remember smoking in public places becoming an issue when I was younger. I however, was too young to even care.
Smoking to this degree is ridiculous. If it poses a problem for people who smoke not to smoke for a couple of hours (say on a airplane) then they seriously need to invest in some gum...or a patch. I, and I'm sure others, would hate to taste smoke everywhere we go.
Luke D'Cunha
Period 2, Government
I think that China's current attitude towards smoking is like America's attitude in the past. At first, Americans thought smoking was "cool;" now it's not--for the most part. I think that as China modernizes, the government will sponsor some sort of anti-smoking campaign, exposing the harms of smoking to all. But it will take some time and lots of effort to do away with China's attitude towards smoking.
This article is interesting, as I was not aware of the amount of cigarette smoking people in China. To me tobacco in general has always been associated with the Western World, but I see now that it is a world-wide habit.
Yeah i don't really like smoking, especially cause i have asthma and it is just not good for you. I also hate the dirty smell that's left all of over you, it's like you took a bath in the smoke of a camp fire.
Wow. I had no idea that China had such a bad smoking problem. Well, is it considered a problem there? Or is it just accepted? Do the government/people recognize it as something they need/want to change? I would hope so. I'm surprised that the Chinese don't have many more severe illnesses.
Tara Viswanathan
2nd Period
This article gives me a migrane.
My father is an avid cigar smoker.
He's an addict but when a doctor asks if he smokes he wil say no.
He just recently had some ugly goo scraped out of his lug.
he was in the hospital for almost a month.
Anyone who consciously decides to pick up smoking is a Freak beyond all belief.
I just recently found out that one of my close friends started smoking cigarettes, " I just do it a few times a month on really stressing days."
Screw that Mr. Perry.
That's all i have to say.
Idiots.
This world is full of idiots who will never go to college and never do anything worth a spit.
Gross Gross Gross.
I Don't Give a crap about what different kinds of cigarettes taste like. What a Waste.
High school is dumb.
Colton Limmer 6th
Well in my opinion I think that smoking is just really gross, not having tried it though.. I do think that it is pretty funny how the Chinese men do prefere some good cigs. I have heard there is not a big difference from cig to cig but that could be false to someone who is a avid smoker. I will continue to not smoke but if I ever try it out, i'll be sure to find some pandas...
I hope you are doing good in Ruidosa
Anjelica Savedra
9th grade
4th period
If you go to China you can find the best kind of ciggrates and cigar's.China's cigars are the worst fumes. The China's kids smoke cigars like crazy.
This story reminds me of my grandparents old stories about how in the 40's and 50's they would get friends together to just smoke and talk about smoke. It's such a revelation in my mind because you rarely see anyone smoking and when you do they look utterly ridiculous or they look like they are about to drop dead. Smoking in China must be like talking about the "big game" just a thing to do. I personally think smoking is disgusting and am somewhat surprised that a country like china has not make any laws as we have.
Smoking is possibly the most disgustiong thing ever. The fact that it is becoming a more attractive habit to others is not reassuring. My dad own smoke shops around town and the people you see going into those stores are gross, old-looking, worn down, disgusting people. I don't find smoking appealing. The fact that it is everywhere does not make it ok. You ruin your life and you lungs smoking, and it affects others as well. Even more so, it is ruining the community. Smoke ruins the atmosphere, the preservation of buildings, children's health,...
smoking is bad. and gross. =(
tat =)
I'm definitely glad that America has cut down on smoking. But, I mean, who am I to tell someone to not smoke? Either way, I'm glad America isn't similar to China in regard to smoking habits.
P.S. As a personal opinion, I think that smoking is extremely unattractive.
P.P.S. Dear Mr. Perry, this is the third account I have had to make.
Rachel Harvill, 3rd
My mom went to China a few years ago, and she said the same, she didn't see one person, men and women alike, who wasn't smoking a cigarette.
I think the new smoking law prohibiting smoking in basically any public place is great. I don't have a problem with other people smoking, I just don't want to have to inhale the toxins as well. It's one's own decision to slowly poison oneself with cigarettes but I'd rather not be poisoned as well, just as an innocent bystander.
However, laws banning smoking in the comforts of your own home or car is taking it a bit too far. Both Vermont and Washington have passed laws banning smoking in homes and vehicles if children are present.
If citizens can't smoke in public places, and not in their own homes, where can they?
Anjalie Schlaeppi, 06
Zeah that is something reallz different between the US and Europe. Here nobody smocks but in Europe, especiallz in France, everzbody smocks... Especiallz youg people, like in my "high school" when we have a 5minutes break, a lot of students are outside, smocking together... And when they come back to class they stink!
But now in France, a law just got passed to make it illegal to smock in public places (in Switzerland it;s the same but I don't know for other countries...). So we'll see if that changes something...
Of course the first thing that I thought when I read this was, wow. Its crazy the things that we don't know about the world. I myself would never take up the terrible habit of smoking counsidering that I have asthma and my lungs are bad enough already, but then again I thought of this in an economic way. Just like i have read in the book Economics in One Lesson, everything we buy or don't buy results in either employment or unemployment, and this disgusting habit gives someone in the world a job then maybe its not such a bad thing after all. Even though it does result in many deaths every day and every year, it probably helps more people keep a job to feed families and prevent starvation. I know i probably sound all cheesy, but I really understand the book and what I learned in economics.
I find it funny that in America today, it is very rare to even have a smoking section in a restaurant, (at least for Lubbock) but in China it has become extremely popular. The quote, “It is better to smoke than to breathe the polluted air,” is funny, because it could very well be true in China’s case.
Kasey Mohler 6th
I absolutely agree with Gillian, i cant believe smoking could make such a social impact.Going to such an extreme to have a conversation starter...i'd rather become a social leper than to even pretend to inhale any kind of cigarette.
well maybe its some form of population control...so i say smoke it up & pass the light...but its pretty funny that you might as well be smoking bc at least its filtered...
I would say that smoking is problem in many oriental countries, vietnam is no exception. Over there, I noticed that smoking is to indicate a men only club. I didn't see one woman smoke, meanwhile the men congregate at various places to blow fumes into the air, a brotherhood pact.
There also may be a difference in constituents of fags/cigars over there. My dad smoked socially in college and everytime he goes back to vietnam but quits whenever he wants with no repercussions (i think).
still don't smoke, smoking makes me cry...because it irritates my allergies
To me, this seems like the way Europeans are with alcohol. Europeans don't drink to get drunk, they do it for the social interaction.
The article did seem a bit too biased toward the positives of cigarettes, however. Doesn't a good article require views from both sides?
I personally think that smoking is disgusting. I met this girl this summer who is from france and she has been smoking for years. when i read the part about different tastes of cigarettes, it reminded me about this girl because whenever she would role her cigarettes the tobacco smelt like coffee. now when i smell coffee i think of smoking and it makes me a little queasy
That's nasty!
There is no good reason to start smoking and the reason it is so polluted there is because of the cigarette smoke. no offense to any cigarette smokers but that is just really gross.
Sarah Lambert
Human Geography AP (4)
9th grade
What an interesting perspective on an awful habit... Have they heard of lung cancer? Hmm.. Oh, and I like that before he started smoking he took cigarettes around with him as a way to make friends... I guess whatever works.
Okay, this is getting unreasonable. Reading all these comments written by others, I can't find many people supporting smoking, it's all "that's gross" and stuff. In order to have discussion, we need to make it two-sided, guys. I'll start us off this time:
Oh, MAN, smoking is AWESOME. The first thing I did when I turned 18 was purchase fifty packs of cigarettes and I smoked them all in one sitting, a pack at a time (I have a very large mouth). It was EU-PHOR-IC! I haven't felt so good since the last time I slept a full eight hours in a single night (you know, before high school). You guys only think smoking is nasty because you've never done it. Skewed perception, isn't it? The secondhand stuff isn't where it's at; you can't effectively judge the goodness of smoking until you're really doing it.
High school is a facility of education. I propose that we have a field trip to a corner store where we buy a bunch of cigarettes and try it out, so we can be educated first-hand about the wonders of smoking.
(disclaimer: I have never smoked in my life, and I don't really plan to either)
Hmm, i'd heard that area was quite into smoking, but that does seem a little extreme. I can understand people smoking, they like it for w/e personal reason suits them, relaxation, w/e, thats fine. What I don't understand is why they would do it soooo much. Maybe it's fun or what have you, but think of your pocketbook. Thats quite the bill you're paying for a rolled up carcinogen bundle.
As for the smoking in public places issue, I honestly don't know what to say on that one. I have -heard- that second hand smoke effects are greatly exaggerated, and assuming such to be true there is really no valid reason to say people can't. Yeah, it smells bad, but it also smells bad when someone hasn't taken a shower for a couple months, and we certainly don't have laws demanding forced showering. If however the effects of second hand smoke were proven to be seriously detrimental, i'd say it should be banned in public places, as you are causing a health hazard to those around you.
I still don't see how people can like those things though, I can barely think or even walk when I smell that smoke, it is utterly hideous.
I don't think anything good ever comes from smoking. It's weird that in different parts of the world habits such as this are so common and welcomed.
I didn't know China had so many smokers. They do it because the air is already so polluted you might as well smoke and enjoy it. But by smoking they are just adding to the problem and hurting themselves a lot faster. Not to mention the smell and what cigarettes do to your teeth. Smoking is not for me.
Although smoking is obviously a serious problem, it is a personal choice that people make about their own lives. On the other hand, breathing polluted air cannot be avoided in most cases, so I believe that laws to curb pollution should be a higher priority than smoking bans simply because pollution can cause worldwide environmental problems in additon to serious health issues.
Post a Comment