Thursday, April 19, 2012

L.A. Times Publishes Photos Against Pentagon Wishes




The facts surrounding the bombshell published today by the Los Angeles Times are not at all in dispute:


* The Times obtained photos portraying soldiers of the Army’s 82nd Airborne Division hamming it up with the remains of Afghan suicide bombers.


* It got the photos from a “soldier in the unit who was himself concerned that the photos reflected dysfunction, in discipline and a breakdown in leadership that compromised the safety of the troops,” Times editor Davan Maharaj said in a web chat about the story.


* The Times had no concerns about the photos’ authenticity. It published two of the 18 photos furnished by the source, to whom it has granted anonymity.


* The Pentagon opposed publication of the photos. A statement released today explains why:
“[Defense Secretary Leon Panetta] is also disappointed that despite our request not to publish these photographs, the Los Angeles Times went ahead. The danger is that this material could be used by the enemy to incite violence against U.S. and Afghan service members in Afghanistan.”


“Disappointed” sounds rather mild, as well it should be. A spokeswoman for the Los Angeles Times and Pentagon officials declined to specify just how much pressure the government exerted on the newspaper to keep the pictures under wraps.


Whatever the case, the Los Angeles Times did the full sweep of due diligence here. It checked with the Pentagon on the story, it vetted the photos, and it showed restraint in publishing only “a small but representative selection” of the photos, in the words of Maharaj.

The position of Pentagon leaders isn’t hard to rationalize. Absent the publicity, they’d have no dangerous externalities to guard against, and they could proceed with appropriate disciplinary measures in any case.


Yet there’s a pivotal figure at the center of this story: $500 billion-plus. That’s what the United States has spent over more than a decade in the war in Afghanistan. The people who are footing that bill have a right to know what they’re funding. In this case, they’re funding yet another on-the-ground scandal. Public support for the war is sagging, and the Los Angeles Times photos won’t buoy it.


Once they stop their pointless scolding of the Times, military officials tend to say the right things about the episode. They are condemning the misconduct. They are deploring it, saying it doesn’t comport broadly with how the war is being prosecuted. One called it “morally repugnant.” As Lt. Col. Peggy Kageleiry told me, “This behavior doesn’t depict the Army’s values.”


Yet publishing this allegedly aberrant behavior surely does comport with American values. The more we know about these photos, the Marine corpse-urination situation and Abu Ghraib, the better.


The Pentagon is saying that U.S. forces in Afghanistan are “taking security measures to guard against” whatever reprisals may arise. If they do, don’t blame the Los Angeles Times.

Military May Have Committed Crimes in Prostitution Flap



If military personnel end up facing criminal charges in connection with the use of prostitutes prior to President Barack Obama's recent trip to Colombia, the military members may have another president to blame for their trouble: President George W. Bush.

Back in 2005, under pressure from human trafficking opponents, Bush issued an executive order making "patronizing a prostitute" a crime under the Uniform Code of Military Justice. The move was aimed at cracking down on military use of prostitutes in peacekeeping operations, but it generated some controversy in places like Germany, where prostitution is relatively well-regulated.

According to Stars & Stripes, U.S. military personnel (and even some of their family members!) complained that the ban made little sense since prostitution was legal and accepted in Germany. Some also doubted that the new provision could or would be enforced. The change in military policy Bush made in 2005 drew notice in Nevada, where the consensus seemed to be that it banned soldiers and sailors from visiting the legal brothels in that state.

Secret Service personnel aren't covered by the UCMJ. There is no similar federal statute that applies to civilians, which raises the possibility that the military folks could wind up with criminal convictions out of this, while the Secret Service agents and uniformed officers just have their jobs at risk.

"You have two different parts of the federal work force performing highly-sensitive missions committing the same conduct and it's possible they'll face substantially divergent outcomes," said Eugene Fidell, a lecturer on military law at Yale Law School.

Of course, it's possible the Secret Service personnel could face more punishment, at least administratively, because there may be fewer comparable cases for them to point to. Military personnel getting in some sort of altercation with a prostitute seems like the kind of thing certain to happen on a regular basis, given the proximity of brothels to military bases in places like Korea, the Philippines

However, Fidell noted that the UCMJ provision isn't simply a straightforward ban on paying for sex. The offense has a few more elements:


‘‘(b)(2) Patronizing a prostitute.(a) That the accused had sexual intercourse with another person notthe accused’s spouse;(b) That the accused compelled, induced, enticed, or procured such personto engage in an act of sexual intercourse in exchange for money or othercompensation; and(c) That this act was wrongful; and(d) That, under the circumstances, the conduct of the accused was tothe prejudice of good order and discipline in the armed forces or wasof a nature to bring discredit upon the armed forces."

Fidell said lawyers might argue that the "wrongful" requirement excuses conduct that was legal in the country where it look place. Prostitution is legal in Colombia, but it's unclear if everything that happened last Wednesday night was entirely legal since the women involved were allegedly picked up at a nightclub/brothel and taken to a hotel.

"They can make the argument that, if it occurred in a place where it was lawful, it doesn't violate that article" in the UCMJ, Fidell said.

The military has already said that at least some of the about 10 servicemembers said to be involved violated curfew. That could amount to a separate UCMJ offense of disobeying an order. Any military officer involved could also face a "conduct unbecoming" charge, which is a separate criminal offense.

Setting criminal charges aside for the moment, both agencies have a pretty effective way of ending the careers of the personnel involved: revoking their security clearances. Many things that are no crime, like failing to pay debts or being married to a suspicious foreigner, can disqualify one from getting or keeping a security clearance. As far as I know, the provisions that bar clearances for people who've used drugs don't take account of where someone was when he or she did that. Like prostitution, drugs are legal in some parts of the world.

For agencies, one benefit of the security clearance route is that the due process due an employee is less than in a straight-up firing. The decision to strip a security clearance can't be challenged in court, even though it has the same effect as firing someone if the job requires a clearance, which both the military and Secret Service do.

The Secret Service has already suspended the clearances of those allegedly involved in the episode. The Service announced Wednesday afternoon that one supervisor involved had retired, another is in the process of being removed for cause, and a line-level employee resigned.

Fidell suggested both agencies will find a way to punish those involved because of the embarrassment and distraction the incident caused.

"At the end of the day, a major presidential exercise of several days duration [was] completely trashed," he said.

Friday, April 13, 2012

Zimmerman to be Charged in Martin Case




JACKSONVILLE, Fla. - Amid furious public pressure to make an arrest in the Trayvon Martin slaying, the special prosecutor on the case went for the maximum Wednesday, bringing a second-degree murder charge against the neighborhood watch captain who shot the unarmed black teenager.

George Zimmerman, 28, was jailed in Sanford - the site of the killing Feb. 26 that set off a nationwide debate over racial profiling and self-defense - on charges that could put him in prison for life.

In announcing the arrest, prosecutor Angela Corey would not discuss how she reconciled the conflicting accounts of what happened or explain how she arrived at the charges, saying too much information had been made public already. But she made it clear she was not influenced by the uproar over the past six weeks.

“We do not prosecute by public pressure or by petition. We prosecute based on the facts on any given case as well as the laws of the state of Florida,” Corey said.

Martin’s parents, who were in Washington when the announcement came, expressed relief over the decision to prosecute the killer of their 17-year-old son.

“The question I would really like to ask him is, if he could look into Trayvon’s eyes and see how innocent he was, would he have then pulled the trigger? Or would he have just let him go on home?” said his father, Tracy Martin.

Many legal experts had expected the prosecutor to opt for the lesser charge of manslaughter, which usually carries 15 years behind bars and covers reckless or negligent killings, rather than second-degree murder, which involves a killing that results from a “depraved” disregard for human life.

The most severe homicide charge, first-degree murder, is subject to the death penalty in Florida and requires premeditation - something that all sides agreed was not present in this case.

“I predicted manslaughter, so I’m a little surprised,” said Michael Seigel, a former federal prosecutor who now teaches law at the University of Florida. “But she has more facts that I do.”

Zimmerman’s new attorney, Mark O’Mara, said Zimmerman will plead not guilty and will invoke Florida’s powerful “stand your ground” law, which gives people wide leeway to use deadly force without having to retreat in the face of danger.

The lawyer asked that people not jump to conclusions about his client’s guilt and said he is “hoping that the community will calm down” now that charges have been filed.

“I’m expecting a lot of work and, hopefully, justice in the end,” O’Mara said.

Zimmerman, whose father is white and whose mother Hispanic, turned himself in earlier in the day and will make a court appearance as early as Thursday.

Corey’s decision followed an extraordinary 45-day campaign by Martin’s parents to have Zimmerman arrested despite his claim that he shot in self-defense. They were joined by civil rights activists such as Jesse Jackson and Al Sharpton, as well as many politicians and supporters in Sanford and cities across the nation.

Protesters wore hooded sweatshirts like the one Martin had on. And the debate reached all the way to the White House, where President Barack Obama observed last month: “If I had a son, he’d look like Trayvon.”

The confrontation took place in a gated community where Martin was staying with his father and his father’s fiancĂ©e. Martin was walking back in the rain from a convenience store when Zimmerman spotted him and called 911. He followed Martin despite being told not to by a police dispatcher, and the two got into a struggle.


Zimmerman told police Martin punched him in the nose, knocking him down, and then began banging Zimmerman’s head on the sidewalk. Zimmerman claimed he shot Martin in fear for his life.

A judge could dismiss the charge based on “stand your ground,” legal experts said. But not if prosecutors can show Zimmerman was to blame.

“If you’re the aggressor, you’re not protected by this law,” said Carey Haughwout, public defender in Palm Beach County.

On Tuesday, Zimmerman’s former lawyers portrayed him as erratic and in precarious mental condition. O’Mara, who signed on after Zimmerman’s previous attorneys withdrew, said that Zimmerman seemed to be in a good state of mind but that the pressure had weighed mightily on him.

“He is troubled by everything that has happened. I cannot imagine living in George Zimmerman’s shoes for the past number of weeks. Because he has been at the focus of a lot of anger, and maybe confusion and maybe some hatred, and that has to be difficult,” the attorney said.

O’Mara also said the difficult case is compounded by the heavy media attention, which might make it hard to seat an impartial jury. Corey, similarly, complained: “So much information got released on this case that never should have been released. We have to protect this prosecution and this investigation for Trayvon, for George Zimmerman.”

Corey, the prosecutor in Jacksonville, was appointed to handle the case by Republican Gov. Rick Scott after the local prosecutor disqualified himself. She has tried hundreds of homicide cases and is known for tough tactics aimed at locking up criminals for a long time and making it difficult to negotiate light plea bargains.

The U.S. Justice Department’s civil rights division is conducting its own investigation. But federal authorities typically wait until a state prosecution is complete before deciding how to proceed.

Tensions had risen in recent days in Sanford, a town of 50,000 outside Orlando. Someone shot up an unoccupied police car Tuesday as it sat outside the neighborhood where Martin was killed. But as the hour of the prosecutor’s announcement neared, the Martin family and their lawyer pleaded for calm.

Outside Sanford City Hall, Stacy Davis, a black woman, said she was glad to see Zimmerman under arrest.

“It’s not a black or white thing for me. It’s a right or wrong thing. He needed to be arrested,” she said. “I’m happy because maybe that boy can get some rest.”

Citizens United to Face SCOTUS Challenge




The Eleventh Amendment Movement (TEAM), a non-partisan citizens group, served a notice on Friday that directly challenges the Supreme Court's constitutional authority to hear an important appeal case involving the controversial 2010 U.S. Supreme Court decision commonly known as Citizens United, and that may immediately result in an effective reversal of that ruling in some states.





Washington, DC (PRWEB) April 13, 2012





The controversial 2010 U.S. Supreme Court decision commonly known as Citizens United may be declared unenforceable and ineffective in the State of Montana and other states, as early as May of this year, after a non-partisan citizens group served a notice on Friday that directly challenges the Supreme Court's constitutional authority to hear an important Citizens United appeal case scheduled for a preliminary ruling on or after April 28th.





The Eleventh Amendment Movement (TEAM), a non-partisan political action association based in Hawaii, will make the claim that, according to the Eleventh Amendment to the Constitution, the high court has no jurisdictional authority to hear an upcoming case involving Montana and Citizens United. If it is determined that the Court does not have jurisdiction to accept the Montana case for hearing, then Citizens United's provisions for unlimited corporate spending in state elections will immediately become unenforceable in Montana and presumably other states.





"The Eleventh Amendment to the Constitution, and related case precedents, clearly indicate that the Supreme Court has no jurisdiction to hear this Montana case," said Adam Furgatch, a spokesman for TEAM, in an interview. "Because the Court should not accept this case, Montana's anti-corruption election laws will then stand, effectively negating the dictates of Citizens United."





Mr. Furgatch explained further, "Contrary to recent news reports, the Court has not yet agreed to take this case and the Eleventh Amendment requires very specific circumstances for the Court to hear cases involving a state government. Those constitutional conditions are seemingly not present here and the Montana case should be denied a hearing."In January, Montana's Supreme Court upheld the state's right to enforce its own anti-corruption election finance laws, in defiance of the federally mandated Citizens United ruling that allows for unlimited corporate spending in state elections. In March, a petition was filed that asks the U.S. Supreme Court to hear the Montana case on appeal and to summarily reverse Montana's ruling. TEAM's attorneys will submit a full legal argument later in April that will ask the Court to deny the petition and to refuse to hear the case on constitutional grounds.





A refusal by the Supreme Court to hear the Montana case would allow the state to continue enforcing its strict anti-corruption election financing and spending laws. In that event, Citizens United's provisions for virtually unlimited corporate spending in state elections would become irrelevant in Montana. The Court's refusal would also serve as precedent for other states to actively enforce their existing election laws or to enact similar laws, with some confidence that the Supreme Court will not overturn them.





Mr. Furgatch stated, "Here is a real opportunity, right now, this month, to essentially reverse Citizens United for this election cycle, without waiting for a Constitutional amendment or for Congress to act, which could take years. We are urgently calling on all states' Governors and attorneys general to support Montana and declare Eleventh Amendment immunity from the Federal judiciary and to claim control over their own elections. It's a states' rights issue, as well as a 'get money out of politics' issue...but we must act quickly."





Supreme Court rules indicate there is a Tuesday, April 17th deadline for the attorneys general of all fifty states to file their own Notice to support Montana with a legal filing, called an amicus curiae (friend-of-the-court) brief. Any state may also sign on to support another state's amicus brief prior to an April 27th deadline to file the final documents.





TEAM's Eleventh Amendment brief is being prepared by experienced Supreme Court litigators and all state attorneys general are urged to contact TEAM to review a draft of the brief. The group's primary message says that all states have a unique opportunity to stand up to the Federal judiciary right here and now, declare state sovereignty, and to enforce the will of the majority of their citizens.





"This is a non-partisan effort that may be endorsed by all those opposed to Citizens United," Mr. Furgatch emphasized. "Political leaders as diverse as President Obama and Senator John McCain agree that the Supreme Court made a colossal error, and polls show that a large majority of voters think Citizens United was a bad decision. Preventing the Supreme Court from grabbing jurisdiction in the Montana case will be a major victory for states' rights and huge blow to those who would profit from unlimited election spending."

North Korean Rocket Ends In Failure




(Reuters) - North Korea's much hyped long-range rocket launch on Friday ended in apparent failure, South Korean officials said, dealing a blow to the prestige of the reclusive and impoverished state that defied international pressure to push ahead with the plan.





North Korea said it wanted the Unha-3 rocket to put a weather satellite into orbit, although critics believed it was designed to enhance the capacity of North Korea to design a ballistic missile deliver a nuclear warhead capable of hitting the continental United States.





A spokesman for the Defense Ministry in Seoul told journalists that the rocket had broken up and crashed into the sea a few minutes after launch.





Officials from Japan confirmed the mission had failed, while ABC News cited U.S. officials saying it had failed, although there was no immediate indication of where it fell.




The rocket's flight was set to take it over a sea separating the Korean peninsula, with an eventual launch of a third stage of the rocket in seas near the Philippines that would have put the satellite into orbit.





This was North Korea's second consecutive failure to get a satellite into orbit, although it claimed success with a 2009 launch and there was no comment on the launch from North Korea's official media.





The Unha-3 rocket took off from a new launch site on the west coast of North Korea, near the Chinese border.





The launch had been timed to coincide with the 100th birthday celebrations of the isolated and impoverished state's founder, Kim Il-sung, and came after a food aid deal with the United States had hinted at an easing of tensions on the world's most militarized border.

Tuesday, April 3, 2012

Obama Targets Romney


President Barack Obama's campaign accused Republican Mitt Romney of siding with "Big Oil" in a new television ad released Monday, signaling an escalation of a general election campaign and a vigorous debate over gas prices.

"In all these fights, Mitt Romney's stood with Big Oil - for their tax breaks, attacking higher mileage standards and renewables," the Obama campaign said in the new ad, which marked the first time the president's campaign has publicly attacked Romney by name and made clear it views the former Massachusetts governor as Obama's likely opponent next fall.

Obama's second ad of the presidential campaign came hours after the release of a similar spot by the Democratic outside group Priorities USA Action, which argued that the oil industry is trying to help Romney win the White House to protect its own profits and tax breaks.

The twin ads sought to blunt a $3 million-plus ad campaign launched by the American Energy Alliance blaming Obama for rising gas prices and his decision to delay the Keystone XL pipeline project. It reflected the degree to which Democrats feel vulnerable as gasoline prices top $4 a gallon in many U.S. markets and pose a threat to the economic recovery, the key benchmark in Obama's case for re-election.

Beyond energy, the ads made clear that Obama's campaign had entered a new stage in which it hopes to define Romney as being beholden to big business well before he secures his party's nomination and seeks to present himself as a viable alternative to Obama.

Romney's campaign and Republicans said the ads reeked of desperation from a White House grappling with high gas prices. Romney spokeswoman Andrea Saul said it was no surprise that Obama was "spending his soon-to-be $1 billion war chest to attack Mitt Romney and deflect blame for his failure to control gas prices."

The Republican National Committee, which is gearing up to help the GOP nominee quickly pivot to the general election, said Obama was "panicked" because his energy policies had "failed to do anything about soaring gas prices that are hurting families across the country."

The ads from the outside groups were airing in states expected to play a deciding role in the presidential election: Colorado, Florida, Iowa, Michigan, New Mexico, Nevada, Ohio and Virginia. The Obama campaign ad was appearing in six of those states but not airing in Michigan and New Mexico.

Obama's campaign has sought to shackle Romney to business and oil interests at a time when oil companies rake in soaring profits. It noted that the American Energy Alliance was run by a former lobbyist for Koch Industries, an industrial firm whose top executives are Charles and David Koch, both prominent supporters of conservative causes.

The ads, however, show the degree to which the Obama campaign needs to defend itself against unlimited money raised by outside groups supporting Republicans. Priorities USA has struggled to compete with some of its Republican rivals, forcing Obama's team to go on the defense and spend money on TV ads seven months before the election.

Appearing with the leaders of Canada and Mexico, Obama faced questions Monday at a White House news conference tinged with presidential politics. Obama defended his health care law following last week's Supreme Court arguments on the constitutionality of his signature accomplishment, saying he expected the court to uphold the law.

Asked about Romney's recent questioning of Obama's support for "American exceptionalism," the notion that America plays a unique role as the world's leading superpower, the president said his "entire career has been a testimony to American exceptionalism."

He then offered a sharp retort against Romney, whose quest for the Republican nomination has dragged into the spring against Rick Santorum and Newt Gingrich. "I will cut folks some slack for now because they're still trying to get their nomination," Obama said.

A few hours later, his campaign had disclosed its plans to strike back at Romney on television.

Old Time Politics


Rick Santorum says a fight at the GOP convention over the party's presidential nominee would be "energizing" for the party.

Campaigning in Wisconsin Monday, Santorum pressed his argument that front-runner Mitt Romney isn't the strongest Republican to go up against President Barack Obama in the fall.

The former Pennsylvania senator says a convention floor fight over which candidate should be Obama's general election opponent would be a "fascinating display of open democracy" and would encourage more Republican voters to participate.

Santorum is far behind Romney in the race for the convention delegates who will choose the nominee. He has acknowledged having little chance of winning the needed 1,144 delegates but notes Romney doesn't have them yet either.

Romney is favored to win Wisconsin's GOP primary Tuesday.